Skip navigation


I would like to make an important note about the myth that people who have borderline personality disorder (BPD) and attempt to commit suicide or otherwise harm themselves in response to fears of abandonment are somehow manipulative. I think this is a common misconception that helps maintain stigma toward persons with BPD and likewise prevents loved ones who might otherwise be supportive from acting in ways that are empathic, assertive, firm but kind, and where setting clear boundaries based upon facts over feelings would serve a better purpose. Now you may think it counterintuitive to think that suicidal threats are not manipulative. However, I think it is extremely important that we understand the differences between feelings associated with another’s suicidal behavior, the intention of another’s behavior, and the reinforcing factors that prompt another’s behavior, which, it seems, are rarely if ever the same thing.

The 2 following paragraphs by Marsha Linehan, BPD’s foremost expert and originator of dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), an evidence based treatment for BPD, suicidal behavior, eating disorders, and other mental health problems aim to lend credibility to my argument,. The first paragraph is from Marsha Linehan’s treatment manual for BPD and addresses the question of suicidal behavior as a form of manipulation, specifically. The 2nd paragraph is from a 32 article issue, Borderline Personality Disorder, that provides an overview of what BPD is and how DBT works to replace dysfunctional behavior with effective behavior through a delicate balance of accepting the person with BPD as he or she is, emotions and all, in order to activate change. Finally, I will restate the information in terms of my argument as simply and factually as possible. Please note that I added the bracketed words to speak to a broader audience not to change the meaning of the content. So, without further due, here’s Marsha.

Unfortunately, the instrumental character of suicide threats and parasuicide is frequently the most salient [prominent] one for therapists and theorists [and anyone] working with borderline individuals. Thus, suicide attempts and other intentional self injurious behaviors are often referred to as “manipulative.” The basis of this reference is usually a therapist’s [Loved one’s or other observer’s] own feeling of being manipulated” … “however, it is a logical error to assume that if a behavior has a particular effect, the actor has therefore engaged in the behavior in order to bring about the effect. The labeling of suicidal behavior as manipulative, in the absence of an assessment of the actual intent of the behavior, can have extremely deleterious effects. (Linehan, 1993 p. 61)

DBT assumes the problems of BPD individuals are twofold. First, they do not have many very important capabilities, including sufficient interpersonal skills, emotional and self regulation capacities (including the ability to self regulate biological systems) and the ability to tolerate distress. Second, personal and environmental factors block coping skills and interfere with self regulation abilities the individual does have, often reinforce maladaptive behavioral patterns, and punish improved adaptive behaviors” … “In DBT, treatment requires confrontation, commitment and patient responsibility, on the one hand, and on the other, focuses considerable therapeutic energy on accepting and validating the patient’s current condition while simultaneously teaching a broad range of behavioral skills. Confrontation is balanced by support. (Linehan, 1997)

In order to see these passages in the context of our discussion and to ensure we are all on the same page, let us now consider the exact definition of the word manipulate which according to the dictionary is, “to handle or use, esp with some skill, in a process or action.” (“Manipulate,” 1991, 1994, 1998, 2000, 2003) Now let us compare this definition to Marsha Linehan’s DBT treatment model which holds that people with BPD commonly do not have, “many very important capabilities, including sufficient interpersonal skills …” Now I ask you how can people with BPD skillfully manipulate a loved one through suicidal actions when the foremost expert on BPD tells us that people who have BPD by and large lack the interpersonal skills required to be manipulative in the 1st place?

So now that you understand why and how suicidal behavior in response to feelings of abandonment is not equal to manipulation, you may still wonder, why then do I feel manipulated? The reason is that, “when people care about what happens to others, they do not want these others to suffer, but they cannot keep misfortune or suffering from happening; they are likely to blame the victims for their own misfortune and suffering.” (Linehan, 1993 p. 63) In other words, when we cannot stop loved ones from suffering, it causes us to suffer, and therefore, in order to stop our own suffering, which is within our power, we attend to blame our loved one, usually without awareness of the function the blame serves. The result is a “feeling” of being manipulated without necessarily being manipulated. The key to overcoming this misconception is being mindful to emotions and learning how to separate feelings from facts.

I hope that we now agree that people who have BPD and engage in suicidal behavior do not meet the definition of being manipulative, but if you remain unconvinced, well, that is okay too. I do not write to tell you what to think; I write to give you things to think about. Therefore, whatever you may believe let me end my argument kindly that it may open your heart where your mind may resist. Compassion is a powerful medicine that everyone can afford. Compassion has no negative side effects. Compassion is caring even if you are angry, disapprove, or disagree with another’s behavior. Compassion is gentle, firm, true, kind, open-minded, and strong. Compassion is a power that comes from within you.

References

Linehan, M. M. (1993). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder (p. 61, 63). New York: Guilford Press.

Linehan, M. M. (1997). Borderline personality disorder. The Journal of the California Alliance for the Mentally Ill8(1). Retrieved June 8, 2013, from http://www.portlanddbt.com/pages/linehan.html

Manipulate [Def. 1]. (1991, 1994, 1998, 2000, 2003). In Collins English dictionary (Complete and unabridged ed.). Retrieved June 8, 2013, from http://www.thefreedictionary.com/manipulate

 

Advertisements

5 Comments

  1. Yes, there are aspects of Borderline Behaviour which are manipualtive though, like Jackie mentioned above.
    From experience, I was once in a really bad place emotionally, but my doctor would not admit me to hospital or prescribe me tranquilising medication, so I took it a step further and overdosed, my intention at that point was not to die, but to be hospitalised so that I could be helped through what I was experiencing emotionally.

    If I think about it honestly, it was manipulative, but it came from a place of desperation.

    On another occasion I was in a space where I felt, F*** everything, life sucks, nobody loves me etc. and then just thought there was no point in living, there was no other goal to the suicide attempt than to escape the pain, the feelings and reactions of family and friends at that time were not a concern of mine.

    To re-iterate what Marsha said, you need to evaluate each case and situation separately.
    It is manipulative if you do it to achieve some sort of desired reaction from people.
    In most cases, suicide attempts never give you a desirable reaction.

  2. Reblogged this on Childhood trauma fact sheet, effects of childhood trauma and commented:
    An interesting article by a fellow blogger

  3. Reblogged this on MAKE BPD STIGMA-FREE!.

  4. I hope this clarifies things for Non-BPDs.

  5. I find the use of “manipulative” very interesting and when it is used it often has a pejorative tone to it. My sense of “manipulation” has to do with indirect means to getting one’s needs met. What I have experienced is when I do not have support (internally, within myself, as in entitlement, or externally, in the environment, as in responsiveness) to ask for what I want and need, I will sometimes resort to indirect means of getting my needs met. This can feel manipulative to another. I too, would caution the individual who is feeling manipulated about the risks of something taught to persons with BPD, that is, the possibility of “emotional reasoning.” It goes something like this: “If I feel it is happening then it must be what is happening.” I applaud the author of this entry to caution those about this type of conclusion. In general, an attempt to get a need met is usually just that. To believe it has another intent, well, there’s something to look at, eh?

    I suspect most of our interpersonal trouble has to do with responding to what we “think” is happening without checking out the individual intentions or clarifying what it is that is being requested. Because persons with BPD more often than not, have grown up in an invalidating environment, and may still find themselves as many people do, in an environment unresponsive to their emotional needs, can you blame a person for being a bit skeptical about getting a healthy response to a simple, direct request?

    I had a teacher once who said, “Need doesn’t care.” What he meant was that although we may indeed RATHER meet our needs directly and with loving support for them, we can’t always do that. Along the way then we learn sideways methods that approximate the need being met but alas, lacking accuracy and attunement, we do so sometimes frustratingly or with great consequence (pain). I try and have a practice of remembering to recognize when I am in pain and feeling especially vulnerable and to ask for what I need as directly and clearly as possible. But also I am learning to have compassion for the experience of sometimes “missing the mark” too and angering others in the process while I grow.


3 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. […] Borderline Personality Disorder & Suicidal Threats: Deconstructing the Manipulation Myth (pinkituscaderro.wordpress.com) […]

  2. […] Borderline Personality Disorder & Suicidal Threats: Deconstructing the Manipulation Myth (pinkituscaderro.wordpress.com) […]

  3. […] Borderline Personality Disorder & Suicidal Threats: Deconstructing the Manipulation Myth (pinkituscaderro.wordpress.com) […]

Comment on this post

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

MAKE BPD STIGMA-FREE!

Helping those with Borderline Personality Disorder fight the stigma and enjoy their lives for who they are - highly empathetic, compassionate and creative people with beautiful minds.

interNational Association of Peer Supporters (iNAPS)

It's about all of us working together to re-humanize healthcare

A Journey Into A Unique Mind

Sharing my journey as a mum with Aspergers, Bipolar, Anxiety and PTSD

Dialectical Behavior Therapy Resources

Samantha Fenno, PhD, LCSW, Lakeview Center for Psychotherapy

Behavioral Research & Therapy Clinics

at the Center for Behavioral Technology

Bipolar For Life

Memoirs of a Wounded Healer

The Borderline Acceptance

The one stop site for learning to love yourself with BPD

DBT Peer Connections

Building Hope, Community and Skillful Means

~~~ ~~~ ~ The DBT-CBT Workbook ~ ~~~ ~~~

The Blog of Melanie Gordon Sheets, Ph.D., the author of the "Out-of-Control" DBT-CBT Recovery Workbook

Turtle Talk

Indigenous Law and Policy Center Blog Michigan State University College of Law

Ron Mills de Pinyas Art

Ron Mills de Pinyas Art

johnritterdotcom

Just another WordPress.com site

Wonderwindy77's Weblog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

mcneae

Just another WordPress.com site

NAMI NW Walk

The official blog for the NAMI NW Walk.

bamartdesign

Just another WordPress.com site

Chaya Leah

Heartscience chayagrossberg.weebly.com

%d bloggers like this: